Editors Blog

Michael Jackson's Legacy: Neither Black Nor White

SPIN's Steve Kandell on the complicated and tortured genius who lived a life none of us ever should.
Michael Jackson Through The Years (Photo: REUTERS/Tobias Schwarz /Landov)
Michael Jackson Through The Years (Photo: REUTERS/Tobias Schwarz /Landov)

Yesterday afternoon, a full 19 minutes after the Associated Press confirmed Michael Jackson's death, a former publicist for the singer sent an e-mail blast to media outlets offering to spill firsthand details of Jackson's "impossibly difficult and often self-destructive journey." And really, who better to sit in judgment of the man's scruples and morals?

But while that offer seemed so repugnantly opportunistic in the moment, even by our culture's standards, before the shock of the news could even settle in, there is little question that someone will take this cretin up on his offer. The dirt is coming, and it's coming soon, and it's coming hard.

The immediate aftermath, though, is meant to be a dirt-free zone, a time to honor Jackson's immeasurable achievements and talent and to somehow untangle those qualities from the baffling mess of his inner life; to separate these two aspects of his character, as if they were indeed distinct entities. Such was the tenor of the cavalcade of talking heads on the teevee last night whenever the words "molestation," "vitiligo," or "Macaulay Culkin" were uttered: "We're not going to talk about that tonight. That's not how he will be remembered."

But in the case of Michael Jackson, to separate the sublime from the surreal would be to miss the very point of what made him such a unique, otherwordly presence -- you could not have one without the other.

Someone who had reached such an unmatched level of ubiquity would simply have to suffer some sort of commensurate turmoil. To emerge from that life wholly grounded and psychically intact would be far more inexplicable than dangling your kid Blanket off a fourth floor balcony. One simply could not be famous since the age of 8 in what could charitably be described as a toxic family situation and go on to create the most successful piece of popular culture in any medium that the world has ever seen without becoming profoundly, deeply fucked up. He experienced the good and the bad in equal, unprecedented ways.

Further, just as the punditry-elite agree that Jackson's is a talent that the world won't see the likes of again, neither is his inscrutable character. Nothing could shine a brighter light on the numbing dullness and transparency of today's class of pop stars than remembering Jackson's divisive weirdness.

Iconic pop stars should be weird and unknowable, that's what we're paying them for. They shouldn't be typing their observations into their iPhones 140 characters at a time; they should be shooting their televisions and comparing themselves favorably to Jesus and collecting African babies at will and sleeping in hyperbaric chambers with well-dressed chimpanzees and possibly, regrettably, kindergartners. Because we cannot. We need them to live lives we'll never know, lives we shouldn't know; to be, if not above the law, then certainly beyond the pale. We're not gonna get this from Ciara and Ben Gibbard, no matter how much we beg.

Us magazine isn't necessarily wrong: Celebrities are just like us -- smile to the cameras as you buy arugula, Kim Kardashian. The mistake is lumping Michael Jackson in with that phylum. He exists -- present tense -- on an entirely different level, and if you were to count off others who might join him there, you wouldn't make it to a second hand.

So brace yourself for the torrents of bad vibes and strange tales coming to a supermarket checkout rack near you soon, and console yourself knowing that while they may be hurtful to the man, they will ultimately only add to his considerable legend. Then remember how important it was to Michael Jackson to be thought of as a legend and hope that just maybe the last derisive laugh will be his.

Comments

j3s2b3w

I hate when people can't accept not not so ~*glorious*~ aspects of their idols.
Like I love Nico and I love her flaws and insaneness as well.
The immediate aftermath is supposed to be dirt-free though, that's ~*~how it is~*~

Branding Sydney

I'm the same age as Michael, actually I'm twelve days older. I happen to be an African American male, but I can assure you that most guys my age no matter what race, or what country for that matter, at some point dreamed of being like Michael Jackson.

Michelle Johnson

Eyes
of a fawn
Illuminated
By a light
Brighter
Than the sun
That rises
At dawn
Innocence immortal
How can it be
That he's gone?
He appeared
An angel
Sent
To save me
From the monsters
In my head
His voice
A joyful noise
Designed
To awaken
The dead
Movement
Like water
Moved me
Beneath
The flesh
At times
When my blood
Seemed
As thick
As lead
How could
A heart
So full
Ever
Stop
Make it stop
The song
That keeps
Playing
In my head
Open your eyes,
Angel,
Show them
You're not dead

wax2metal

Regardless of what this man did or did not do, you cannot deny the impact he had on millions in the early 80s. Thriller, hands down is the number one POP albums ever made. Seems to me way too many musicians die at a young age; Elvis, Kurt Cobain, Jimmy Hendrix, Michael Jackson the list goes on. Whether it is due to drugs, emotional distress or recklessness it really doesn't matter. The struggles between following your dream and fame seems to be very conflicting and it takes a strong person to stay grounded enough to handle both. How do you not believe the hype when you are a household name, really? How do you walk away from a situation humbled when all you are told is how wonderful you are? How do you distinguish the difference between a true friend and someone just blowing smoke up your ass because they want to tag along for the ride? Either you believe it and become some bizarre parody of yourself or you are a freakishly stable person who is so grounded you remain true to yourself and appreciate the gift you've been given. I think the latter is obviously more heroic and should be celebrated but I also think it must be the hardest to maintain. The USA is a country that loves to put its stars on a pedestal but we love to kick that pedestal out from under them just as quickly. That for one is sad to me but inevitable I suppose. I think there is a whole market missing in the Therapy world that could help musicians, actors, etc, transition into stardom with a secure and REALISTIC outlook on this journey, which will in turn guide them through a successful career not cut short by the hype. Unfortunately, Michael had all the odds stacked against him; child star, unstable family life and the most famous pop star in the world. What we see as a blessing may actually be a curse. The Britney's, Lindsay's and others could very well be tomorrows tragic story. Again not all turn out bad but even one tragic loss is enough.

Barrett

You tabloids will blame anyone for Michael Jackson's reclusiveness - except YOURSELVES, won't you?

The man was NOWHERE NEAR as "weird" as you defined him to be.

I understand defining him that way allowed YOU to sell your crap and get website clicks - but it helped lead him to his drug addiction (IF he was addicted and I'm not convinced) and to his DEATH.

WHEN WILL YOU LOOK IN THE MIRROR when asking the question of what and how this iconic, brilliant man was destroyed to his death.

Eh?

Barrett

I will ADD that PART and PARCEL of the "odds stacked against him" --

WAS THE TABLOID MEDIA.

That means YOU.

Anonymous

Who the heck is Steve Kendall?!

Got something to say?

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • No HTML tags allowed
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Use <!--pagebreak--> to create page breaks.

More information about formatting options

Are You Human?
If so, enter the four-letter code below to post your comment.
Image CAPTCHA