Fall Out Boy have set some lofty ambitions for themselves this year. First, they dubbed their comeback album Save Rock and Roll, then they hoped to make fans, uh, “kick the shit out of your bedroom at your parents’ house” with the Ryan Adams-produced Pax Am Days EP. But on November 18, the reunited emo-pop outfit settled for a more modest goal: close out Jimmy Kimmel Live! with two thrilling performances. And that’s exactly what the Chicago crew pulled off with their late-night twofer highlighting Save Rock and Roll fist-pumpers “Alone Together” and “My Songs Know What You Did in the Dark (Light Em Up).” Watch the former above and the latter below. Sorry, neither clip features any Victoria’s Secret fashion models.