Devendra Banhart, 'What Will We Be' (Reprise)
Nobody comes to a Devendra Banhart record for trenchant insight into the human condition. "All my thoughts are hairs on a wild, wild boar," he muses here on "Chin Chin & Muck Muck." Instead, Banhart's albums offer ashram-appropriate guitar strums, trippy-hippie tone poetry and, if you're lucky, at least one tune where he sings from the perspective of a rodent. What Will We Be has all that (check out "Rats"), plus a wee-hours piano-bar ballad and a driving soul-rock jam with more Tom Petty than Vashti Bunyan in it. A big improvement over 2007's ho-hum Smokey Rolls Down Thunder Canyon, it's also the most consistently satisfying full-length he's made.
Fans of Banhart's outré tendencies might be surprised that this is also his first major-label disc; after all, he doesn't really seem like the compromising sort. Yet, working alongside producer Paul Butler (from the U.K.'s A Band of Bees), Banhart actually flourishes with a little direction: In the catchy campfire singalongs "Angelika" and "Goin' Back," his appealing eccentricity gains potency when it's packed into more compact forms, while "Baby" and "16th & Valencia, Roxy Music" shimmer with a newfound professionalism. What Will We Be sags toward the end with a handful of snoozy acoustic shuffles and a wack-ass impersonation of the Doors. But mostly, it clicks. Maybe wild boars can be broken.












SPIN BOASTS SNARKY REVIEWS.
Banhart has a larger following than trippy-neo-hippies. There is a juxtaposition of intellectual and whimsical throughout most of his songs. Smokey Rolls....Canyon did not do as well as anticipated according to the rest of is catalogue however, he supports a genuine artistic constant feed which continues to mature and sharpen. I'm concerned that reviews like this will direct Banhart to become a more "accessible" artist/musician. I'm hoping that he is still a bird who cannot be caged.
SPIN REVIEWS LOWER MORAL. I suggest returning to Lady GaGa's right tit.
Or bending over for the next Discovery album.
Cheers!
I do not think you have anything to worry about and Banhart will remain as inaccessible as ever. Besides, if he does allow himself to be caught and caged then he really was not the free bird we all thought him to be. A truly free artist is few and far between and the process of becoming "accessible" is not just a change in the music but something that was always lurking deep within. If Banhart were to listen to every review ever written about him then you, I, and the other masses would be surely disappointed.
D. Banhart
RIP
Banhart sounds more like Paul Simon. Where are lyrics like "Put me in your dry dreams..."?
Got something to say?