When: 1991, Super Bowl XXV, New York Giants (W) vs. Buffalo Bills (L)
Who: New Kids on the Block, Mickey Mouse and the gang
Boom: The swag coming off the one in the bucket hat. Also: a song ostensibly about five college-age guys trying to get laid dedicated to the children of America's armed forces.
Bust: Is this what used to pass for a halftime show? Bring back Fergie.