Magazine

25 Greatest Live Bands Now!

Take a sneak peek at this feature from Spin's Sept. issue!

Sure, you can stay at home and download music to your ears' content. But sometimes it's all about the Show. Whether in a dingy club, on a muddy festival field, or in a shining stadium, these artists are guaranteed to set off rock'n'roll pyrotechnics, literal or otherwise.

WRITTEN BY: Charles Aaron, Andrew Beaujon, Doug Brod, Rob Kemp, Melissa Maerz, and Brian Raftery

25
COMETS ON FIRE
Years back, with Ethan Miller's roaring guitar, Utrillo Kushner's splattering drums, and Noel Harmonson's disorienting Echoplex, Comets on Fire raged like a belligerent action painter hurling glops of blue, black, red, green, purple, and yellow in your face. It was, um, jarring but nothing you really needed to experience again. Now, after injecting some nuance and texture, the band, joined by folk-drone guitarist Ben Chasny, gradually unveil their kaleidoscopic sound rather than just blinding you with it. And you can't stop staring, no matter how loud the colors get.
BEST MOMENT:
The next day, when the ringing in your ears stops.

24
THE MARS VOLTA

The Mars Volta barely acknowledge their audience, admittedly a distraction when your songs have roughly two dozen "movements" apiece, but somehow that aloofness is more engaging than any overpaid legend trying to see which side of the arena can clap louder. Chalk that up to singer Cedric Bixler Zavala's mutant dance moves or to a band that always manages to be tighter than guitarist Omar Rodriguez-Lopez's trousers.
BEST MOMENT:
You know that part in "Drunkship of Lanterns" where everything drops away but weird belching noises, then the drummer slowly brings it back, and then Bixler Zavala wails like Robert Plant, and you suddenly understand what your loser uncle meant when he said you had to see Zeppelin to understand how amazing they were? That.

23
AFI
Davey Havok has conquered the fabric of time and space -- just notice how whenever he jumps into the crowd, he reappears, Captain Kirk–like, back onstage. And he jumps into the audience a lot, a good way to remind you that, while AFI managed to look like one of the biggest bands in the world long before they were one, their connection with their fans is absolute. So when dragged along boyfriends lift their lighters ironically during the "Morningstar" interlude, they're quickly put in their place. Also, you gotta love between-song patter along the lines of "Thank you for being so vivacious tonight."
BEST MOMENT:
Havok stands on audience members' hands during the set closer "Totalimmortal," and what starts off resembling a fascist rally (taped Gregorian moans augmented by crowd chanting) begins to look a bit like church.

22
LCD SOUNDSYSTEM
Have you ever watched a movie detective chase someone through a crowded nightclub and thought, "C'mon, that's not what rock shows are really like"? Well, LCD Soundsystem shows are exactly like rock shows in the movies -- lights blind the audience, the sound is deafening, the band barely moves, and the singer looks as though he does something else for a living (say, minor-league hockey team equipment manager). And it's really hard to push through the crowd members, their arms outstretched, eyes closed, bodies vibrating more than dancing. For some reason, when frontdude (and DFA label mogul) James Murphy gets wasted and makes fun of them, they like it even more.
BEST MOMENT: Murphy -- and this is not something we say lightly -- is actually pretty good on the cowbell. But don't shout "More cowbell!" He can't hear you, and "Beat Connection" is better for it.

21
AGAINST ME!
Matted hair, inflamed faces, black jeans and T-shirts soaked with sweaty grime. Wry, woozy grins. Spirited banter with the pit jockeys down front. When Against Me! take the stage, they look like they just drove ten desperate hours in a van to rock you arseways, then buy you a pint and crash on your floor after a red-eyed debate about what the hell it means to call yourself an anarchist after opening for Green Day in football stadiums. Then they wake up, start mainlining El Pico, and do it all over again.
BEST MOMENT:
When the music drops out on "Sink, Florida, Sink" and the whole place explodes with one voice: "They make all the right reasons to fuck it up / You're gonna fuck it up / Whoa whoa-oh-oh-oh-ohhh!"

Comments

WillyB

Radiohead behind the Chili Peppers? Is that some sort of a cruel joke? I've seen both live in the past two years. I cried and laughed and sang at Radiohead. I slept at the Chili Peppers. Radiohead concerts are the absolute most incredibly fantastic, intimate, beautiful, incredible, and amazing atmospheres ever.

Jonathon Scott Johnson

Bull-shit list. Has no one at Spin ever been to an Incubus concert. Hands down the best live band alive. Top five live band of all time. They dont even make the list??? I have lost all hope in Spin's musical taste and list making skills. Go to a show, you will become a believer.

myusername

Rammstein is the best live band, end of story.

Colinlyons

A top 25 without Muse? is that a joke, they are the best live band in the world hands down

Anonymous

How is pearl jam not on this list?

TehVex

Yeah, seriously I'm with you Colinyons, Muse is by far the best live band ever, not even having them somewhere in a top 25 list is bull...

Anonymous

no PEARL JAM?!?!? Yikes, guess that makes this list absolute nonsense.

Haywood Chablomi

yea this list is bullshit plain and simple, whoever the fuck made this should eat a dick, its offending to not include some of the more that worthy bands on here, another band that probably is top 5 ever DAVE MATTHEWS BAND...they are infamous for their shows..but they are just 1 of many missed, and the names that made the list arent even in respective order...just so sad someone actually made this list, fucking idiots

Nick

These lists are always subjective, so to you poor little darlings who are a bit thin skinned hold on to you what ever security you choose and listen to uncle nick, America is not the centre of every one's musical universe, so to add my tupence the best Rock show I ever saw was Midnight oil on there 1984 tour of Australia, but I applaud this list because I love music and so does the Author.

An ominous

The top of the bullshit is U2 at #1. That explains it all. Every list who undergoes that temptation falls immediately into a void of banality and incompetence. Probably who wrote down the list is just another huge U2 fan.. please give us a break. And take a look around, too!

Anonymous

and u r just another U2 hater. read up about u2 before u say anything like this pls.

Anonymous

No Muse? are they serious??? they are without a doubt the greatest live band of all time.

Lizard Person

Anyone ever heard of Phish? This list is a joke. How can they ignore one of the best live bands of the last 20 years?

Here come the haters!

One Trojan Horsepower

No Rammstein?No Nine Inch Nails?Come on....

Anonymous

really no pearl jam?!! this is amateur list obviously...

Anonymous

One word that is missing.... MUSE

Rose

I can't believe Muse is not on the list!

Jerry

No Umphrey's McGee? Seriously the best live band out there right now. Better than Phish, better than moe. and way better than U2.

Anonymous

Rage Against the Machine????????
?????????????????????????????

Anonymous

Pearl Jam rapes most bands live..they gotta be on this list.

Zack de la Rocha

Damn YOUUU Spin Staff! Rage forever!!!

Chelsie

Wow...the lack of Muse makes this list ridiculous. Unbelievable.

Got something to say?

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • No HTML tags allowed
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Use <!--pagebreak--> to create page breaks.

More information about formatting options

Are You Human?
If so, enter the four-letter code below to post your comment.
Image CAPTCHA